• Magazine
  • Firewall Daily
  • Essentials
    • Regulations
    • Compliance
    • Governance
    • Policy Updates
  • Knowledge Hub
  • Features
    • Cyber Warfare
    • Espionage
    • Workforce
      • Learning & Development
  • Business
    • Startups
    • Mergers & Aquisitions
    • Partnerships
    • Appointments
    • Budgets
    • Research
      • Whitepapers
      • Sponsored Content
      • Market Reports
    • Interviews
      • Podcast
  • Events
    • Conference
    • Webinar
    • Endorsed Events
  • Advisory Board
The Cyber Express
  • MagazineDownload
  • Firewall Daily
    • All
    • Bug Bounty & Rewards
    • Dark Web News
    • Data Breach News
    • Hacker News
    • Ransomware News
    • Vulnerabilities
    Jensen Huang resigns

    Jensen Huang Exits Nvidia Days After the Board Said It Backed Him

    FaceStealer

    US Disrupts North Korea’s FaceStealer Campaign, Targets $1.2 Billion in Stolen Crypto

    SignDrop zero-day exploit

    New SignDrop Exploit Claims SYSTEM Access on Windows Through CLFS

    Microsoft 365 Outage

    Why Did Outlook Go Down? Microsoft Traced It to Its Own Servers

    WorkOS, AI Agent, Prompt Injection, Grok, Grok AI, Gemini, Fraud, Agentic AI, AI-assisted Cyberattacks

    WorkOS Says a Researcher’s Runaway AI Pentest Agent Copied Customer Sales Records

    Nvidia board investigation

    Why Is Nvidia Investigating Its Own CEO, and Can the Board Remove Him?

    weekly roundup

    The Cyber Express Weekly Roundup: FBI Blames North Korea for $6B Binance Hack, Hackers Turn Up the Heat on Europe’s Fridges and More

    Stockal cyberattack

    Stockal Confirms Unauthorized Trades in 13 Customer Accounts

    Alpine Linux servers

    Alpine Linux SSH Flaw Lets Attackers Log In Without a Password

    Trending Tags

    • blackbyte ransomware
    • Ransomware
    • lapsus$ ransomware
    • Apple
    • Apple vulnerability
  • Essentials
    • All
    • Compliance
    • Governance
    • Policy Updates
    • Regulations
    SEC, Misleading Cyber Disclosures, Financial data, financial data protection, SEC

    SEC Enforcement Fell 24% in Fiscal 2026

    ASD Essentials

    The Essential Eight Is Being Replaced: What Australian Organisations Need to Know

    SICW 2026

    AI Is Now Fighting on Both Sides of the Cyber War, Singapore Warns

    Morocco cybersecurity strategy

    Morocco Flags AI Threats, Prioritizes Critical Infrastructure Defense

    European Police Chiefs Convention 2026

    Europe’s Police Chiefs Face Growing Threat of AI-Driven Crime

    AI service security

    Hackers Are Stealing AI Keys. The Cost Can Reach $600,000

    AI security risks

    Sam Altman at UN Security Council: 6 AI Security Risks the World Cannot Ignore

    AI-enabled cyber attacks

    AI Gives Hackers an Edge Defenders Still Can’t Match, NCSC Warns

    Fraudulent SIM cards

    India’s DoT Warns Citizens Over SIM Fraud and IMEI Tampering

    • Regulations
    • Compliance
    • Governance
    • Policy Updates
  • Knowledge Hub
    • All
    • How to
    • What is
    Infostealer Intelligence

    The 2026 Infostealer Intelligence Shortlist: Top 10 Vendors Security Teams Should Know

    Google Chrome

    How to Remove Saved Passwords From Google Chrome (And Why You Should)

    DPDP Rules, Cyble, DPDP Act, Cyble Vantage

    How Cyble’s Front-Row Vantage Can Help You in Complying to India’s DPDP Act

    Cybersecurity Countries

    The Top 8 Countries Leading the Cyber Defense Race in 2025

    link building

    The Link Building Secrets Your Competitors Don’t Want You to Know

    Supply Chain Attack

    Supply Chain Resilience and Physical Security: Lessons for 2025

    Healthcare cybersecurity trends of 2024

    Healthcare Cybersecurity: 2024 Was Tough, 2025 May Be Better

    CEO's Guide to Take-Down Services

    Shield Your Organization: CEO’s Perspective on Take-Down Services

    Azure sign-in Microsoft

    Microsoft Announces Mandatory MFA for Azure Sign-ins to Bolster Cloud Defenses

  • Features
    • Cyber Warfare
    • Espionage
    • Workforce
      • Learning & Development
  • Business
    • All
    • Appointments
    • Budgets
    • Mergers & Aquisitions
    • Partnerships
    • Press Release
    • Startups
    Kerala Police Signs MoU With Cyble

    Kerala Police Signs MoU With Cyble to Use Threat Intelligence in Cybercrime Probes

    Gemini 4 Argon

    Gemini 4 Argon Restricted Over Cybersecurity Misuse Risks

    weekly roundup September 18 2026

    The Cyber Express Weekly Roundup: Hiscox’s SMB Warning, a Nintendo Switch Flaw, and a Record Deepfake Takedown

    threat intelligence

    Cyble, UAE Cyber Security Council Unite Against Rising Cyber Threats

    Ukraine cybersecurity

    Zelensky Appoints Ihor Klymenko to Lead Ukraine’s Cybersecurity Center

    UK cyberattack rate

    UK Small Firms Bear Brunt of Rising Cyberattacks, Hiscox Finds

    Cyber Yodha Campaign

    Cyble and DRONA Launch New Push to Close India’s Cybersecurity Gap

    UK Ukraine AI partnership

    Britain Gains Access to Ukraine’s ‘Goldmine’ of Battlefield AI Data

    Hims & Hers lawsuit

    FTC Sues Hims & Hers Over Health Data Privacy, Billing Practices

    • Startups
    • Mergers & Aquisitions
    • Partnerships
    • Appointments
    • Budgets
    • Research
      • Whitepapers
      • Sponsored Content
      • Market Reports
    • Interviews
      • Podcast
  • Events
    • Conference
    • Webinar
    • Endorsed Events
  • Advisory Board
No Result
View All Result
  • MagazineDownload
  • Firewall Daily
    • All
    • Bug Bounty & Rewards
    • Dark Web News
    • Data Breach News
    • Hacker News
    • Ransomware News
    • Vulnerabilities
    Jensen Huang resigns

    Jensen Huang Exits Nvidia Days After the Board Said It Backed Him

    FaceStealer

    US Disrupts North Korea’s FaceStealer Campaign, Targets $1.2 Billion in Stolen Crypto

    SignDrop zero-day exploit

    New SignDrop Exploit Claims SYSTEM Access on Windows Through CLFS

    Microsoft 365 Outage

    Why Did Outlook Go Down? Microsoft Traced It to Its Own Servers

    WorkOS, AI Agent, Prompt Injection, Grok, Grok AI, Gemini, Fraud, Agentic AI, AI-assisted Cyberattacks

    WorkOS Says a Researcher’s Runaway AI Pentest Agent Copied Customer Sales Records

    Nvidia board investigation

    Why Is Nvidia Investigating Its Own CEO, and Can the Board Remove Him?

    weekly roundup

    The Cyber Express Weekly Roundup: FBI Blames North Korea for $6B Binance Hack, Hackers Turn Up the Heat on Europe’s Fridges and More

    Stockal cyberattack

    Stockal Confirms Unauthorized Trades in 13 Customer Accounts

    Alpine Linux servers

    Alpine Linux SSH Flaw Lets Attackers Log In Without a Password

    Trending Tags

    • blackbyte ransomware
    • Ransomware
    • lapsus$ ransomware
    • Apple
    • Apple vulnerability
  • Essentials
    • All
    • Compliance
    • Governance
    • Policy Updates
    • Regulations
    SEC, Misleading Cyber Disclosures, Financial data, financial data protection, SEC

    SEC Enforcement Fell 24% in Fiscal 2026

    ASD Essentials

    The Essential Eight Is Being Replaced: What Australian Organisations Need to Know

    SICW 2026

    AI Is Now Fighting on Both Sides of the Cyber War, Singapore Warns

    Morocco cybersecurity strategy

    Morocco Flags AI Threats, Prioritizes Critical Infrastructure Defense

    European Police Chiefs Convention 2026

    Europe’s Police Chiefs Face Growing Threat of AI-Driven Crime

    AI service security

    Hackers Are Stealing AI Keys. The Cost Can Reach $600,000

    AI security risks

    Sam Altman at UN Security Council: 6 AI Security Risks the World Cannot Ignore

    AI-enabled cyber attacks

    AI Gives Hackers an Edge Defenders Still Can’t Match, NCSC Warns

    Fraudulent SIM cards

    India’s DoT Warns Citizens Over SIM Fraud and IMEI Tampering

    • Regulations
    • Compliance
    • Governance
    • Policy Updates
  • Knowledge Hub
    • All
    • How to
    • What is
    Infostealer Intelligence

    The 2026 Infostealer Intelligence Shortlist: Top 10 Vendors Security Teams Should Know

    Google Chrome

    How to Remove Saved Passwords From Google Chrome (And Why You Should)

    DPDP Rules, Cyble, DPDP Act, Cyble Vantage

    How Cyble’s Front-Row Vantage Can Help You in Complying to India’s DPDP Act

    Cybersecurity Countries

    The Top 8 Countries Leading the Cyber Defense Race in 2025

    link building

    The Link Building Secrets Your Competitors Don’t Want You to Know

    Supply Chain Attack

    Supply Chain Resilience and Physical Security: Lessons for 2025

    Healthcare cybersecurity trends of 2024

    Healthcare Cybersecurity: 2024 Was Tough, 2025 May Be Better

    CEO's Guide to Take-Down Services

    Shield Your Organization: CEO’s Perspective on Take-Down Services

    Azure sign-in Microsoft

    Microsoft Announces Mandatory MFA for Azure Sign-ins to Bolster Cloud Defenses

  • Features
    • Cyber Warfare
    • Espionage
    • Workforce
      • Learning & Development
  • Business
    • All
    • Appointments
    • Budgets
    • Mergers & Aquisitions
    • Partnerships
    • Press Release
    • Startups
    Kerala Police Signs MoU With Cyble

    Kerala Police Signs MoU With Cyble to Use Threat Intelligence in Cybercrime Probes

    Gemini 4 Argon

    Gemini 4 Argon Restricted Over Cybersecurity Misuse Risks

    weekly roundup September 18 2026

    The Cyber Express Weekly Roundup: Hiscox’s SMB Warning, a Nintendo Switch Flaw, and a Record Deepfake Takedown

    threat intelligence

    Cyble, UAE Cyber Security Council Unite Against Rising Cyber Threats

    Ukraine cybersecurity

    Zelensky Appoints Ihor Klymenko to Lead Ukraine’s Cybersecurity Center

    UK cyberattack rate

    UK Small Firms Bear Brunt of Rising Cyberattacks, Hiscox Finds

    Cyber Yodha Campaign

    Cyble and DRONA Launch New Push to Close India’s Cybersecurity Gap

    UK Ukraine AI partnership

    Britain Gains Access to Ukraine’s ‘Goldmine’ of Battlefield AI Data

    Hims & Hers lawsuit

    FTC Sues Hims & Hers Over Health Data Privacy, Billing Practices

    • Startups
    • Mergers & Aquisitions
    • Partnerships
    • Appointments
    • Budgets
    • Research
      • Whitepapers
      • Sponsored Content
      • Market Reports
    • Interviews
      • Podcast
  • Events
    • Conference
    • Webinar
    • Endorsed Events
  • Advisory Board
No Result
View All Result
The Cyber Express
No Result
View All Result

Navigating the Ransomware Dilemma: To Pay or Not to Pay Ransom Demands?

The ongoing deliberation regarding whether companies should make cyber ransom payments showcases compelling arguments from both perspectives.

Ashish Khaitan by Ashish Khaitan
August 7, 2023
in Firewall Daily, Ransomware News
0
ransom payments
585
SHARES
3.2k
VIEWS
Share on LinkedInShare on Twitter

Ransom payments are swiftly becoming routine aftermath of cyber attacks. Whether companies should pay cyber ransom or not has continued to be a topic of intense debate among security experts.

Although numerous businesses struggle with deciding whether paying such ransoms would effectively halt the attack or worsen the situation, federal cybersecurity agencies firmly oppose ransom payments.

As countries worldwide participate in dialogues regarding the prospect of reevaluating their approach to ransom payments, Australia, having experienced a significant surge in cyberattacks over recent years, leading to profound repercussions on its security and various sectors, is deliberating the implementation of a comprehensive prohibition on ransom payments.

Nonetheless, Michael Rogers, the former director of the US National Security Agency, holds a contrary opinion on this matter, deeming it unfavorable. Instead, he proposes adopting a risk-based strategy that takes into account a specific set of essential criteria.

“Australia should not impose a blanket ban on paying cyber ransoms but instead adopt a risk-based approach that considers a set of key criteria”, said Rogers as reported by The Australian Financial Review.

Australia’s cybersecurity posture and approach to ransom payments

Recently, Australia has seen an increase in hacker activity, giving rise to a variety of ransomware attacks. According to the Australian Cyber Security Centre (ACSC) Annual Cyber Threat Report, roughly 76,000 cybercrime incidents has happened between 2021-2022, making Australia a prime target of hackers.

The discussions around the legality of cyber ransom payments have gained momentum in Australia. Home Affairs Minister Clare O’Neil has consulted with industry stakeholders, recognizing the complexity of the issue.

While the government’s forward approach to cybersecurity places Australia in a favorable position, questions remain about the best course of action regarding ransom payments.

Retired Admiral Michael Rogers, a seasoned security expert, advocates for a paradigm shift in approaching cyberattacks. He cautions against measuring success solely by the ability to prevent penetrations, asserting that a determined adversary can often find a way into even the most secure systems.

“This is what I used to tell the two presidents, ‘Sir, if the metric you’re going to use it anytime we have a significant penetration that is a failure, then you are going to be incredibly frustrated,'” Rogers told The Australian Financial Review.

Instead, Rogers proposes a new metric: evaluating how effectively an organization responds to attacks and mitigates their impact.

Rogers’ argument prompts us to consider the fundamental question: Should companies be permitted to pay cyber ransom payments, or should such payments be unequivocally discouraged?

Rogers advocates for a risk-based approach that weighs key criteria before considering ransom payments. Factors such as loss of life, health, national security, and economic stability should be carefully evaluated against the risk of ransom payments.

The former NSA director suggests that this deliberation should be a partnership between government and industry, avoiding unilateral decisions that could lead to negative consequences.

“With a determined adversary who is focused on you as a target and who was prepared to commit resources, it is very difficult to ensure 100 percent that they will not penetrate your system,” added Rogers. 

The two sides of ransom payments

The ongoing debate over whether companies should pay cyber ransom payments features compelling arguments on both sides. The allure of swift data recovery must be balanced against the potential pitfalls of emboldening cyber adversaries and funding illicit activities. 

Beyond legal implications, cyber ransom payments raise ethical concerns. Succumbing to extortion demands may embolden cyber adversaries, prompting them to target more organizations and fuel ransomware distribution.

Moreover, there is the potential for ransom payments to fuel illicit activities, as highlighted by a US Department of the Treasury’s OFAC advisory.

Lowers Forensics International emphasizes that opting to pay cyber ransom payments can expose organizations to unforeseen legal challenges.

Mirroring the stance of government bodies, including the FBI, these organizations discourage ransom payments. The crux of the legal predicament lies in the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA) and the Trading with the Enemy Act (TWEA).

The allure of ransom payments is evident: a possible path to swiftly regaining access to crucial data and systems. The State of Ransomware 2021 report by Sophos shows that paying a ransom doesn’t guarantee complete data restoration.

On average, only 65% of data is recovered, and a mere 8% of organizations successfully retrieve all their data. Encrypted files might remain irrecoverable, and the promised decryption tools could fail or even lead to further complications.

Cybersecurity advocate Fortinet asserts that while no explicit law prohibits ransom payments, a consensus discourages such actions from both US government authorities and cybersecurity experts. Influential organizations like CISA, NCSC, the FBI, and HHS urge victims to exercise caution despite the temptation to regain control over compromised data.

The fundamental uncertainty lies in the unpredictable outcomes of ransom payments, as retrieval of files remains far from guaranteed.

Media Disclaimer: This report is based on internal and external research obtained through various means. The information provided is for reference purposes only, and users bear full responsibility for their reliance on it. The Cyber Express assumes no liability for the accuracy or consequences of using this information.

Share this:

  • Share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn
  • Share on Reddit (Opens in new window) Reddit
  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • More
  • Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
  • Share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp

Related

Tags: cyber ransomRansom PaymentsThe Cyber ExpressThe Cyber Express News
Previous Post

ALPHV/BlackCat Ransomware Group Targets Pakistan, Claims IBL Healthcare Cyber Attack

Next Post

Recruitment Company Delaney Browne Targeted in Cyber Attack by 8BASE

Next Post
Delaney Browne cyber attack

Recruitment Company Delaney Browne Targeted in Cyber Attack by 8BASE

Q1 2026 Threat Reports

❮ ❯
Cyble-Vision


Follow Us On Google News

Categories

  • Privacy Statement
  • Terms of Use
  • Write For Us

© 2026 The Cyber Express - Cybersecurity News and Magazine.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

No Result
View All Result
  • Magazine
  • Firewall Daily
  • Essentials
    • Regulations
    • Compliance
    • Governance
    • Policy Updates
  • Knowledge Hub
  • Features
    • Cyber Warfare
    • Espionage
    • Workforce
      • Learning & Development
  • Business
    • Startups
    • Mergers & Aquisitions
    • Partnerships
    • Appointments
    • Budgets
    • Research
      • Whitepapers
      • Sponsored Content
      • Market Reports
    • Interviews
      • Podcast
  • Events
    • Conference
    • Webinar
    • Endorsed Events
  • Advisory Board

© 2026 The Cyber Express - Cybersecurity News and Magazine.

-
00:00
00:00

Queue

Update Required Flash plugin
-
00:00
00:00